The blank garment is half the finished product — sometimes more. The design matters enormously, but if the shirt doesn't fit right, feel right, or hold up through washing, none of the printing quality matters. We've printed on Bella+Canvas, Next Level, and Comfort Colors thousands of times each, and the differences are real, meaningful, and worth understanding before you order.
This isn't a sponsored post and we don't have a financial incentive to push any particular brand. We'll give you the unfiltered comparison based on what we actually experience printing on these fabrics day after day.
| Factor | Bella+Canvas 3001 | Next Level 3600 | Comfort Colors 1717 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fabric weight | 4.2 oz | 4.3 oz | 6.1 oz |
| Material | 52% cotton / 48% poly | 60% cotton / 40% poly | 100% ring-spun cotton |
| Fit | Retail fitted, unisex | Very fitted, slight stretch | Boxy, relaxed, slightly oversized |
| Softness | Very soft out of the box | Extremely soft, jersey feel | Soft, gets better with washes |
| Print surface | Excellent — very flat | Good — slight texture | Good — slight heathered texture |
| Shrinkage | Minimal — pre-shrunk | Minimal — pre-shrunk | Moderate — order up if in doubt |
| Vintage / lived-in feel | No | No | Yes — the defining characteristic |
| Price tier | Mid-premium | Mid-premium | Premium |
| Best for | Most use cases | Lifestyle & fashion brands | Vintage aesthetic, lifestyle brands |
If you've bought a retail-quality blank tee from a brand you respect in the last five years, there's a meaningful chance it was a Bella+Canvas 3001. It's become the de facto standard for premium custom printing across the industry, and for good reason: it performs consistently, fits modern retail proportions, and provides an excellent print surface for both screen printing and DTF.
The 3001 is a slim, retail-fitted cut. It's shorter and narrower than a traditional tee — someone who typically wears a large in a Gildan should usually size up to XL in the Bella. The shoulder seam sits right at the shoulder tip, sleeves are shorter (intended to be about mid-upper arm), and the body is tapered through the torso. This fits the way most modern people expect a t-shirt to fit: worn, not draped.
The 52/48 cotton-poly blend is soft immediately out of the packaging — no break-in period required. The polyester content keeps the fabric from shrinking significantly (pre-shrunk, typically <2% further shrinkage after washing). The slight synthetic content also gives the shirt a subtle drape and elasticity that full-cotton shirts lack.
Excellent. The surface is flat and consistent, which is ideal for screen printing. Colors pop on the Bella because the tight weave doesn't absorb as much ink as heavier cotton fabrics. DTF transfers adhere cleanly. The white Bella 3001 is our most popular print substrate by volume — it's the shirt we default to when a customer asks "what would you recommend?"
Almost everyone. Events, teams, organizations, branded merchandise, sample runs. It's not the cheapest option and not the most premium, but it hits a quality-to-cost ratio that makes sense for the widest range of use cases.
Next Level built their reputation on fabric softness, and the 3600 delivers it. If you've ever worn a t-shirt that felt like a jersey athletic shirt — soft, lightweight, with a slight stretch — that's the Next Level 3600. It's become extremely popular in the streetwear and lifestyle brand space specifically because it feels different from a standard tee in a way that shoppers immediately notice.
The 3600 fits similarly to the Bella+Canvas 3001 in terms of being modern and retail-fitted, but the fabric has a bit more stretch to it — the 60/40 blend with ring-spun cotton gives it a jersey quality that moves with the body. Some people find this fit slightly roomier than the Bella in the same size; others find it more fitted because the stretch accommodates more without looking baggy.
At 4.3 oz, it's in the same weight range as the Bella, but it feels noticeably lighter and softer because the ring-spun cotton and the knit construction give it a different texture. The stretch means it recovers from washing without the stiffening that some cottons develop over time.
Good, with some caveats. The slight texture of the fabric means DTF and screen prints don't have quite the same perfectly flat surface as on the Bella — the weave shows slightly under close inspection. On dark colors, this isn't noticeable at all. On white or very light shirts with detailed artwork, it can be. For most designs and most use cases, it prints beautifully. Just be aware if you're doing very fine detail work.
Brands where the physical feel of the shirt is part of the product. Streetwear, fashion-oriented merchandise, wellness brands, yoga studios, boutique gyms. If someone is paying $30–$45 for your branded tee, the Next Level fabric feel helps justify that price point.
Comfort Colors makes a fundamentally different product than Bella or Next Level. The 1717 is a 100% ring-spun cotton heavyweight shirt that's garment-dyed after construction — meaning the entire shirt is dyed as a finished garment, producing the slight color variation, soft hand, and vintage-washed look that's become the defining aesthetic for a specific category of brands.
The 1717 is a boxy, relaxed cut — intentionally so. It's not a modern retail-fitted shirt. It's wider in the body, the shoulders are slightly dropped, and the overall silhouette reads as vintage or oversized even in smaller sizes. People who prefer oversized fits love this. People expecting a modern fitted shirt are often surprised. Size down if you want a more tailored look; wear your normal size or size up if you want the full vintage boxy effect.
At 6.1 oz, the 1717 is significantly heavier than the Bella or Next Level. The garment-dyeing process creates a slightly inconsistent color across the shirt — this is intentional and is exactly the aesthetic that makes Comfort Colors shirts visually distinctive. The fabric gets softer and more broken-in with every wash, which is the opposite of how most tees behave.
This is the main practical gotcha with Comfort Colors: the 1717 shrinks more than pre-shrunk garments. Expect 3–5% shrinkage over the first few washes, potentially more. We strongly recommend ordering up one size if you're close between sizes, and recommending that end customers wash cold and air-dry for the first wash if they're concerned about fit.
Good, but the heathered texture of the garment-dyed fabric means print detail isn't as crisp as on the Bella. Colors appear slightly muted on Comfort Colors because the fabric texture diffuses the ink slightly. This actually works in the aesthetic's favor — a slightly worn-looking print on a slightly vintage-looking garment reads as intentional and on-brand. It's perfect for that aesthetic. For clinical brand accuracy and maximum color pop, use the Bella instead.
Lifestyle brands, vintage-aesthetic merchandise, craft businesses, coffee shops, record stores, surf and skate brands, farm-to-table restaurants — any business where the "worn-in, not corporate" aesthetic is part of the brand identity. The Comfort Colors look is immediately recognizable and has become shorthand for a certain type of thoughtfully positioned consumer brand.
We carry Gildan and print on it regularly. It's a perfectly legitimate choice — particularly for high-volume orders where cost is the primary consideration, or for workwear and events where the shirt is functional rather than a branded product statement. The Gildan 5000 at 5.3 oz is a heavier, more traditional fit that runs larger than the premium brands. For orders of 100+ pieces where budget matters significantly, Gildan can save $1–$3 per piece compared to Bella or Next Level — which adds up meaningfully at scale.
For most orders, Bella+Canvas 3001 is the right default choice. It's the industry standard for a reason — consistent quality, great print surface, modern fit, widely understood sizing. If you have a specific aesthetic goal (maximum softness → Next Level; vintage/lifestyle → Comfort Colors) or a specific budget constraint at very high volumes (→ Gildan), those are the alternatives worth considering. We're happy to send samples if you're ordering a significant quantity and want to feel the fabric before committing.
Select your preferred brand in the order form, or choose 'No preference' and we'll default to Bella+Canvas 3001. Free proof on every order.
Start your order →